Tired of being a nice guy

I’ve been told that I am too nice to girls, which is why I am single. As a nice guy, I am tired of finishing last, so how do I be mean to girls?

Robert, 29
Answered by:

Nice Guys often face a perspective dilemma – they believe they must choose between nice and mean. We are so lost in our Nice Guy identities that we don’t see the alternative options. I was like this for most of my life. I thought being nice was option 1, and being an asshole was option 2. There was no option 3. So when girls told me I was too nice, I would get frustrated and think “What, you want me to be a prick? Fine, you asked for it!”

I tried being mean for a while, and it did actually “get” girls. In reality, what happened is that being a prick allowed some deeply insecure girls to become briefly attracted to me, because they mistook it for confidence, or they had unresolved Daddy issues. And I hated myself for being this way – I don’t enjoy treating people like garbage. So being mean was not my ideal situation, either. For a while I was lost. Being nice didn’t “work”, but being mean felt awful and fake. I felt like there was no way out. Until I saw the truth.

Both Nice and Mean are fake and manipulative. What Nice and Mean have in common is that they are strategies designed to manipulate people’s emotions. I was stuck because I was trying to choose a good manipulative strategy to make people like me – which is the secret Nice Guy agenda – and so I couldn’t see any better options.

Yet, the best option was right in front of me all along: Stop trying to make people like you. You’re stuck between a rock and hard place because you’re coming from the starting point of neediness. Neediness is a turn-off for anyone who is psychologically healthy. Your biggest issue is that you’re unwilling to let girls dislike you. You think of yourself as Nice, but your niceness is just a performance to make girls like you.

You’ve probably never really tried to be authentic with women you’re attracted to. Being genuine is truly attractive – to the right girls for you. Some will love you for who you are, others won’t. But for you to find this out, you’ll need to stop both niceness and meanness – both of these are forced, strategic manipulations that hide who you truly are. The difficult part is learning how to stop trying to make people like you.


Your privacy is important to us and we will never rent or sell your information.


Go up